Maybelline Super Stay Teddy Tint, Long Lasting Matte Lip Stain, Wild At Heart, 0.17 fl oz

10 reviews for Maybelline Super Stay Teddy Tint, Long Lasting Matte Lip Stain, Wild At Heart, 0.17 fl oz

1. 

   5 out of 5

   Vineferia – June 6, 2025

   Long lasting coverage
   Most lipstick will not last on me. Not Maybelline super stay! It lives up to its name. At first it feels wet but you get used to it. The color is beautiful and rich.

2. 

   5 out of 5

   Anne – April 29, 2025

   Best I’ve tried
   It actually works!! Forget the lip stains and all the TikTok ads. This stays on my lips, is a beautiful shade, and stays ALL DAY. And nothing has done that for me

3. 

   4 out of 5

   GayK – May 28, 2025

   Good but not great
   This color is very much a nude. It comes close to my natural coloring. The texture of the lip stain is a little thick and sticky. It does not dry quickly. I’d put it more in the category of a gloss than a stain – the color doesn’t last all that long. Frankly, I’m surprised it’s gotten the hype that it has. Still, it works well enough, and I do like the shade. It is certainly affordable. Just prepare to reapply. Also, it’s difficult to wash off of a drinking glass. STays longer on a glass than it does on your lips.

4. 

   4 out of 5

   andrianna – May 3, 2025

   Top 3 Lipsticks!
   I don’t usually write reviews AT ALL! But i’ve been looking for a lipstick to match my natural lip, AND stay on! The colour isn’t super pigmented but it’s just enough. Ive washed my face with soap and used a makeup wipe and it’s still stayed on and has barely faded. The only fallback is how long it takes to dry, but it’s worth it! Will be buying again!

5. 

   4 out of 5

   Bee – April 6, 2025

   new teddy
   The new teddy tints are very velvety. goes on smooth. does feel a little heavy on the lips at first, but then drys mat, and you dont feel like you’re wearing a lip gloss or lip stick. i don’t think it’s long lasting. it does work more like a lip stain. the more you apply, the darker it gets. I like that about them. great color to choose from.

6. 

   3 out of 5

   KJ – April 2, 2025

   Needs a better formula
   Pros: The color is so pretty. It’s a soft pink that looks absolutely beautiful with my complexion. It’s become my favorite for everyday because I rarely wear much makeup.

   The staining and staying power is legit. It takes a longer time to dry than most stains but once it’s set it stays through eating and drinking and lasts most of the day. The color is so subtle that fading is barely noticable but a darker color would probably still show. Overall though, as a stain, I think it’s really great.

   Cons: Only one con but its a pretty big one. This is supposed to be matte. It certainly looks matte when applying and when dry. But when it’s completely dry my lips become incredibly sticky. Like stick together sticky. Even if I pat off execess it’s still sticky. The weird part is no color comes off. It’s just sticky. Putting a lip gloss top coat over it (not an oil, that will ruin the color) works. It fixes the sticky and the color still lasts. Once the gloss wears off? Sticky again. So even though it says matte, without the gloss, I find it unwearable, so it doesn’t get to stay matte. I probably won’t purchase again for this reason but I’ll use the color I got.

7. 

   3 out of 5

   Kari – March 30, 2025

   Just okay
   I’m on the hunt for a good lip stain, and this is not it. It left a wee bit of color on my lips after blotting, but it also transferred quite a bit still after that. So the second time I used it, I wiped off as much as I could so it wouldn’t transfer. There wasn’t much color left that wasn’t my lips being a little raw from the rubbing/scrubbing with tissue. It’s also rather sticky feeling unless it’s all the way wiped off.

8. 

   3 out of 5

   WalmartCustomer – April 30, 2025

   
   It’s supposed to be a lip stain but is more of a liquid lipstick. It doesn’t stain and it doesn’t wear evenly. It doesn’t last anywhere near as long as advertised. Reapplication is necessary throughout the day. Pretty shades though.

9. 

   2 out of 5

   Goodpurchase – March 17, 2025

   False presentations from manufacturer
   Not really color stay came off in 10 minutes didn’t eat or drink and it was gone. Also didn’t come wrapped properly during shipment. One of my items was wrapped up and sealed in plastic. The other three were not they came directly from the store, not so satisfying not really color stay came off in 10 minutes didn’t eat or drink and it was gone. Also didn’t come wrapped properly during shipment. One of my items was wrapped up and sealed in plastic. The other three were not they came directly from the store,

10. 

    1 out of 5

    Carol – January 19, 2025

    Don’t get it
    The color its beautiful but I don’t feel like this is a tiny, it’s really creamy and dries off on your lips so bad that they crack. I am not sure if I got an original one but got another color also the same issue I HATE IT and feels so sticky, Maybelline has better lipsticks or tints this is just not what everyone else said, probably the good reviews are fake reviews just to sell the product but my review it’s an honest one.